⚖️ Helal Calls for Consistent Sanction Standards
Former international referee Sami Helal addressed the issue of disciplinary sanctions imposed on referees, stressing that the same standards should generally apply to everyone regardless of the referee’s reputation, experience or status within the refereeing system.
Helal explained that consistency in disciplinary measures is important for maintaining fairness within the refereeing committee and ensuring that referees understand that sanctions are based on clear and established standards.
📢 A Referee’s Name Should Not Affect the Penalty
Sami Helal emphasized that, in his view, a sanction should not vary depending on the identity of the referee who made the mistake.
He argued that a referee’s name or position should not become a reason for applying different standards, while consistent disciplinary rules could help strengthen confidence among referees and clarify accountability when mistakes occur.
🧠 The Psychological Side Matters
At the same time, Helal pointed out that dealing with referees is not limited to administrative punishment, noting that the psychological aspect can also play an important role, particularly when a referee is returning from a major crisis or difficult period.
He explained that offering support in such circumstances can have a psychological justification, especially when the objective is to help the referee regain confidence and return to his previous level.
🔍 Ahmed El Ghandour’s Case
Helal also discussed the situation of Ahmed El Ghandour, stating that the referee had been going through a problem and needed support as part of his return.
The example highlights the importance of looking at referees from more than one perspective, rather than focusing solely on punishment and ignoring the role of psychological support in helping officials overcome difficult periods.
🟨 Mostafa Hassan and the Need for One Standard
Helal also referred to Mostafa Hassan, the assistant referee in the Pyramids vs Eastern Company ENPPI match, noting that the fact that he is in the final year of his refereeing career should be taken into consideration when assessing his situation.
However, Helal returned to his main point: sanctions should ultimately be applied to all referees according to the same standards, regardless of names or individual circumstances.
🏟️ Fairness Within the Refereeing System
Sami Helal’s comments highlight the balance between applying disciplinary rules consistently and considering the psychological and human dimensions of refereeing, particularly in cases that require a broader assessment.
As competitions continue, the way referees are evaluated and sanctioned remains an important issue within the refereeing system, especially when different cases generate debate over whether the same standards are being applied consistently.
